Class or Community?

Marx, the Russian Commune, and Contemporary Critical Theory

Alfredo Macías Vázquez, Pablo Alonso González, and Eva Parga Dans

Volume 60, Number 1 (2021)

This article explores the relationship between class and community through a discussion of peasant struggles and the commune during the Russian Revolution. Doing so, we show how Marx’s class-oriented reflections on community can help us to understand the role that the peasantry plays (or should play) in processes of social transformation. This enables us, first, to understand the relevance of communal forms for Marx, who believed that communitarian ways of life were crucial for overcoming a value-based society. It is, in fact, a mistake to divide Marx’s intellectual trajectory into two periods: a categorical Marx, who authored Capital and critically analyzed the classical theory of value, and a phenomenological, empirical Marx, who in the last years of his life abandoned writing Capital and focused instead on studying the Russian peasantry. Second, it enables us to discuss new externalist visions, such as postcolonial and decolonial theories, which postulate that the subordination of contemporary peasant communities is rooted in epistemology, culture, and local power relations. These theories are related to the old social-democratic canon, which conceives of social classes as preconstituted entities and of capital as a parasitic externality that is incommensurable with social dynamics. The experience of the Russian peasantry calls into question all externalist and ontological perspectives.

Image: “On Mir,” by Sergey Korovin (1893), from Wikimedia Commons

Image: “On Mir,” by Sergey Korovin (1893), from Wikimedia Commons

 
Previous
Previous

Trauma Delegitimized

Next
Next

1. Times of the Event: An Introduction